Quick answer: Vitamin D helps your body absorb calcium and keep bones and muscles working, and in winter many women make little from the sun. But large trials, including VITAL with nearly 26,000 adults, found that supplements did not prevent fractures or improve strength in people who were not deficient. Getting enough matters, more is not better, and testing makes most sense if you have risk factors. Ask your clinician whether to test before you supplement.
By mid-November, many of us leave for work in the dark and get home in the dark, and our runs happen under streetlights or on a treadmill. That is when vitamin D starts showing up in conversations, group chats and pharmacy aisles. It does matter for women over 40. But the research on supplements is more modest than the hype, and it is worth knowing what it actually shows.
The short answer: enough matters, more is not better
Vitamin D helps you absorb calcium and keeps bones and muscles working, and in winter many women make little from sunlight. Getting enough matters. But large trials found that extra vitamin D did not prevent fractures or improve strength in people who were not deficient. If you might be low, ask your clinician whether to test, rather than guessing.
That is not a reason to ignore vitamin D. It is a reason to treat it as one piece of bone and muscle health, alongside the pieces with stronger evidence: lifting heavy, impact work, enough protein and calcium, and not smoking.
What vitamin D does for bone and muscle
Vitamin D’s main job is helping your gut absorb calcium and keeping calcium and phosphate levels steady, which bones need to stay strong. Without enough, bones can soften and thin over time. Muscles also have vitamin D receptors, and severe deficiency can cause weakness and aches, which is why low levels matter more for women who train.
According to the NIH Office of Dietary Supplements, vitamin D also plays roles in nerve, muscle and immune function. That is real physiology. What is less clear is whether taking more than you need adds anything, and that is where the trials come in.
It also matters more in your 40s and beyond because bone loss speeds up around menopause as estrogen falls. Our page on exercise for bone density in menopause covers what builds bone best.
Why winter makes a difference
Your skin makes vitamin D from strong sunlight. In winter, at the latitudes where most of the US, Canada and Europe live, the sun sits too low for much to be made, even on bright days. Short days, indoor training, covering up, darker skin and sunscreen all cut production further. Levels tend to dip by late winter.
Some groups are more likely to run low, according to the NIH Office of Dietary Supplements:
- People with darker skin, which makes less vitamin D from the same sun.
- People who rarely get sun on their skin, including those who train indoors, work nights or cover up.
- People with conditions that limit fat absorption, such as Crohn’s disease, celiac disease or ulcerative colitis.
- People who have had weight-loss surgery, or who have a higher body fat level, since vitamin D is stored in fat.
- Older adults, whose skin makes vitamin D less efficiently.
What the big trials actually show
The best evidence comes from large randomized trials, and their message is consistent: in people who are not deficient, extra vitamin D does not prevent fractures or falls or build strength. The trials mostly enrolled people with normal levels, so they say less about people who are truly low, who need proper treatment from their clinician.
The biggest is VITAL. LeBoff and colleagues, 2022 (New England Journal of Medicine) followed 25,871 adults, about half of them women aged 55 and over, for a median of 5.3 years. A daily vitamin D supplement did not lower total, nonvertebral or hip fractures compared with placebo. The effect did not change with baseline vitamin D levels, though few participants were very low.
A review of 81 trials by Bolland and colleagues, 2018 (Lancet Diabetes and Endocrinology) found vitamin D had no effect on total fractures, hip fractures or falls, and no clinically meaningful effect on bone density. For muscle, a VITAL substudy of 1,054 people by Chou and colleagues, 2024 (Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism) found two years of supplements did not improve grip strength, walking speed, balance or chair stands.
More can be worse. In a trial by Sanders and colleagues, 2010 (JAMA), 2,256 women aged 70 and over were given a single very large yearly dose or placebo. The vitamin D group had 15 percent more falls and 26 percent more fractures, mostly in the months after each dose.
These trials were mostly in older adults with normal vitamin D levels, so they do not tell us much about a 45-year-old who is genuinely low. They do make two things clear: vitamin D is not a shortcut to stronger bones or muscles, and very high doses can do harm. Deficiency is diagnosed and treated by a clinician, not by a supplement aisle.
Should you get tested?
Testing makes most sense when you have a reason. US screening guidance says the evidence is too thin to recommend testing everyone without symptoms, and the Endocrine Society advises against routine testing in healthy adults. But a test is often worthwhile if you have risk factors, and it beats guessing at a dose. Ask your clinician.
The US Preventive Services Task Force, 2021 (JAMA) found the evidence insufficient to judge whether screening adults without symptoms helps. The Endocrine Society’s 2024 guideline (Demay and colleagues, Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism) suggests against routine testing in the general population and against taking more than the standard recommended intake for disease prevention in healthy adults under 75.
Reasons to raise it with your clinician:
| Situation | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Low bone density, osteoporosis or a past fragility fracture | Vitamin D status is part of the bone workup |
| Crohn’s, celiac, ulcerative colitis or weight-loss surgery | Absorption of vitamin D can be poor |
| Very little sun on your skin, or darker skin | You make less vitamin D, especially in winter |
| Medicines that affect vitamin D, such as some seizure drugs or long-term steroids | They can lower levels |
| Bone pain, muscle weakness or aches with no clear cause | These can be signs of deficiency |
If you are having bloodwork anyway for a perimenopause check-up, it is a good moment to ask whether vitamin D belongs on the list, alongside things like iron and ferritin.
Food and sunlight
Few foods are naturally rich in vitamin D. Oily fish, such as salmon, trout, sardines and mackerel, are the best sources, with smaller amounts in egg yolks and mushrooms grown under UV light. Many milks, plant milks, yogurts and cereals are fortified, so check the label. In summer, short periods of sun on bare skin add more.
On sunlight, there is no safe tanning formula, and sunburn raises skin cancer risk. Getting outside for walks and runs in daylight through the warmer months is the sensible middle ground. In winter, food and, if your clinician suggests it, a supplement carry more of the load.
Vitamin D is not the main event for bones
If you want strong bones and muscles after 40, vitamin D is the support act. The main event is training: lifting heavy, adding impact and jumps, and eating enough protein and calcium. Those have far stronger evidence than any supplement, and they also help balance, which protects you from the falls that break bones.
For the impact side, our guide to plyometrics for bone density shows how to start safely. And if you are curious which supplements our coach Kristina uses herself, she shares her perimenopause supplement stack, with the same advice to test your level rather than guess.
Where Phaes fits
Phaes has free lab tracking, so you can log a vitamin D result, or any other bloodwork, and see the values over time. The Doctor Ready Report gathers your logged labs, symptoms and MHT (HRT) history into one export to share with your clinician. Phaes does not interpret results or recommend doses. Your training plan handles the lifting and impact.
The bottom line
Vitamin D matters for women over 40, especially in winter, but big trials like VITAL show that extra vitamin D does not prevent fractures or build strength in people who are not deficient, and very high doses can cause harm. Eat oily fish and fortified foods, get daylight in summer, ask your clinician about testing if you have risk factors, and put most of your effort into lifting, impact and protein.
Frequently asked questions
Do women over 40 need vitamin D supplements?
Not automatically. Women need enough vitamin D, and some do not get it in winter, especially with little sun, darker skin or certain health conditions. But big trials in people who were not deficient found little benefit from extra. Ask your clinician whether you are at risk and whether a test or a supplement makes sense for you.
Does vitamin D prevent fractures?
In people who are not deficient, the trials say no. The VITAL trial of 25,871 adults found no drop in total, nonvertebral or hip fractures over about five years, and a review of 81 trials found no effect on fractures or falls. People with true deficiency or osteoporosis are a different group, and their treatment is a matter for their doctor.
Does vitamin D help muscle strength?
In generally healthy adults, supplements did not improve grip strength, walking speed or balance over two years in a VITAL substudy of more than 1,000 people. Lifting heavy and eating enough protein have much stronger evidence for muscle. Severe deficiency can cause muscle weakness, which is one reason testing matters if you have risk factors.
Should I get my vitamin D level tested?
If you have risk factors, ask about it. US and Endocrine Society guidance does not support routine testing for everyone, but a test is often reasonable with low bone density, a condition that affects fat absorption, weight-loss surgery, very little sun, or medicines that affect vitamin D. A test beats guessing at a dose.
Can you take too much vitamin D?
Yes. Vitamin D is stored in the body, and very high intakes can raise calcium to harmful levels. In one trial, older women given a single very large yearly dose had more falls and fractures than those given placebo. Stick to what your clinician recommends, and count all your sources, including multivitamins.
What foods are high in vitamin D?
Few foods are naturally rich in it. The best are oily fish such as salmon, trout, sardines and mackerel, plus egg yolks and mushrooms exposed to UV light. Many milks, plant milks, yogurts and cereals are fortified, so check the label. Most people get some from food and the rest from sun in the warmer months.
